Global Tax Disputes Update - March 2018 | KPMG Global
Share with your friends
Global Tax Disputes Update

Global Tax Disputes Update - March 2018

Global Tax Disputes Update

Global Tax Disputes Update - March 2018

With tax audit and dispute activity rising in almost every country, keeping up with trends and developments is more important than ever. In this edition, you’ll find briefings on key news, events and thought leadership submitted by Global Tax Dispute Resolution & Controversy professionals in KPMG member firms worldwide. Staying informed can be a crucial first line of defense as you manage your disputes around the globe.

Make sure to view our past issues of Global Tax Disputes Update.

Insights from around the world


ATO guideline on cross-border related-party financing arrangements, transactions

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) released a ‘practical compliance guideline’ on its approach to tax issues associated with cross-border related-party financing arrangements and related transactions.

Read the article.


Opportunity for reduced penalty and interest for India-based companies providing technical services

For taxpayers identified by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) as being affected by the Full Federal Court’s decision in the Tech Mahindra Limited case, the deadline is nearing for engaging with the ATO and benefiting from the considerable tax concessions on offer.

Read the article.


Constitutional Court’s decision on ‘fairness tax’

The Belgian Constitutional Court issued a decision that ‘cancels’ provisions of the law that introduced the ‘fairness tax’. However, the court upheld the consequences of the law for assessment years 2014 to 2018 (except for provisions that are in breach of the European Union Parent-Subsidiary Directive on redistributed dividends).

Read the article.


Introduction of the innovation income deduction regime

Belgium’s new innovation income deduction regime complies with the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s (OECD) Action Plan on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting. The regime foresees a deduction of 85 percent of qualifying income. The regime applies not only to patents, including product and production process patents, but also to copyright-protected software.

The regime has been subject to an increasing number of tax and transfer pricing audits, and a significant number of companies seeking to use the regime have opted to obtain an advance unilateral ruling with the Belgian tax administration. Applying for a ruling avoids lengthy and time-consuming disputes with the Belgian tax authorities and offers legal certainty to the taxpayers concerned.

KPMG in Belgium has assisted and advised numerous companies in a variety of industries seeking rulings, guiding them through the ruling process and delivering the necessary economic and transfer pricing analysis to support their proposed innovation income deduction claims.

Further information:
Dirk Van Stappen


Corporate income tax and taxability of state tax incentives

The First Section of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) has clarified whether incentive tax credits (i.e. ICMS presumed credits) granted to taxpayers by the Brazilian states should be as part of the tax basis for Brazil’s corporate income tax (IRPJ) and social contribution on net profits (CSLL).

The court ruled (RESP Nº 1.517.492 – PR) that tax incentives granted by the states cannot be taxed by the federally since this would damage the Federation Principle. The court also ruled that taxpayers are entitled to refunds of tax paid on such incentives in the last 5 years.

However, since the tax authorities are not bound by this decision, taxpayers need to claim these refunds through an administrative or judicial proceeding.

Further information:
Marcos H M Matsunaga


PIS and COFINS tax credits: court win for taxpayers

On 22 February 2018, the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) extended the concept of ‘inputs’ for calculating PIS and COFINS (valued added tax) credits. The court decided that the tax credits should be calculated on all acquisitions of goods and services that are essential for producing goods or for rendering services. The court also ruled that the Normative Instructions n. 247 and 404, which provided the tax authorities’ understandingregarding the PIS and COFINS tax credits, are illegal. 

The controversy over PIS and COFINS tax credits is a major cause of tax disputes and litigation in Brazil at the federal level. Although there is still room for discussion about the meaning of ‘essential’ in specific situations, the STJ ruling provides guidance and represents a major win for taxpayers.

Further information:
Marcos H M Matsunaga


Changes to ‘tax haven’ and ‘privileged tax regimes’ lists, transfer pricing implications

Costa Rica, Madeira and Singapore have been removed from the list of ‘tax havens’ in Brazil. However, certain specific regimes within those jurisdictions are listed as ‘privileged tax regimes’.

Read the article.


New ‘education’ audits of charities by Canada Revenue Agency

The Canada Revenue Agency has initiated a new educational program to help charities comply with their tax obligations and avoid common errors.

Read the article.


Interim customs administrative measures on advance rulings

China’s General Administration of Customs issued new guidance on its advance rulings program:

— One announcement summarizes interim administrative measures on advance rulings that are effective 1 February 2018. Read the article.

— A second announcement, issued 31 January 2018, clarifies further details of the interim administrative measures. Read the article.


Czech Republic

Binding rulings, determining tax base of permanent establishments

Beginning 1 January 2018, taxpayers may ask the tax administrators for binding rulings on the manner of determining the tax base of a permanent establishment (or a registered branch of a foreign entity) located in the Czech Republic.

Read the article.


Proposed changes to income tax law for 2019

The first draft of an amendment to the income tax law, released by the Ministry of Finance for comments, would implement certain tax law changes expected to be effective in 2019.

Read the article.


Changes in VAT law expected in 2019

The Czech Ministry of Finance submitted a draft amendment to the value added tax (VAT) law that would take effect in January 2019. Among other things, the amendment would transpose new European Union (EU) regulations into Czech legislation and harmonize existing Czech regulations with EU legislation and interpretations of the Court of Justice of the EU.

Read the article.


Cross-border loss relief rules; deductibility of losses from foreign permanent establishments

An advocate general of the Court of Justice of the European Union (EU) issued an opinion on the compatibility with EU law of the Danish rules on the deductibility of losses from foreign permanent establishments.

Read the article.


Deductibility of losses from Danish permanent establishment when head office not Danish tax resident

An advocate general of the Court of Justice of the European Union (EU) issued an opinion on the compatibility with EU law of the Danish rules on the deductibility of losses from a Danish permanent establishment whose head office is not tax resident in Denmark.

Read the article.


‘Beneficial owner’ when back-to-back financing by non-resident parent company

An advocate general of the Court of Justice of the European Union (EU) issued three milestone opinions regarding the interpretation of the beneficial owner concept in cases where the Interest and Royalties Directive and the Parent-Subsidiary Directive are applicable.

Read the article.

European Union

Review of CJEU judgments, CJEU Advocate General opinions, infringement procedures and referrals

The 17 January 2018 edition of e-News from the EU Tax Centre offers a round-up of Court of Justice of the European Union (EU) decisions and opinions and other tax developments that can have both a domestic and a cross-border impact.

Read the article.


Tax audit trends

In the last few years, France’s International Tax Audit Department appears to have sharpened its focus on financing schemes, with particular attention to interest rates, thin capitalization and substance. KPMG in France is now seeing more and more tax disputes on financing schemes, most recently involving the French anti-hybrid mechanism introduced in 2013.

Under this mechanism, interest is not tax-deductible in France where it is not subject to corporate income tax in the lender’s country at a rate equal to at least 25 percent the French corporate income tax. This mechanism covers not only hybrid instruments but also standard loans granted by lenders located in a low-tax jurisdiction.

This matter is likely to be subject to litigation if the French Tax Authorities maintain their broad interpretation of the rules.

Further information:
Audrey-Laure Illouz


Draft of law for creating a trust relationship

The French Parliament is considering a draft law for creating a trust relationship between the state and citizens. If it is passed by Parliament, some of the draft law’s provisions will have tax impacts.

One purpose of the draft law is to officially recognize the right to make mistakes. For tax matters, in cases of spontaneous regularization, interest for late payment would be reduced by 50 percent and penalties would not be applied.

If enacted, the law would also entitle taxpayers to a written opinion from tax inspectors on the topics they investigated during a tax audit and enhance taxpayers’ ability to request rulings to obtain certainty on proposed tax positions.

Further information:
Audrey-Laure Illouz


Tax waiver on capital reclassification held ‘state aid’

The General Court of the European Union upheld a decision of the European Commission for France to recover approximately 1.37 billion euros (EUR) from Électricité de France. The amount recovered represents ‘state aid’ in the form of a waiver of the tax on the reclassification of rights in capital.

Read the article.


Decision expected to address constitutionality of anti-avoidance tax provision

The French Constitutional Court is expected to issue a decision on the constitutionality of an anti-avoidance tax provision concerning the rules on the recapture of financial expenses of a French tax group on acquiring a corporation. The decision could affect the application of other French tax avoidance rules.

Read the article.


Participation exemption, dividends originating in third countries

An advocate general of the Court of Justice of the European Union (EU) issued an opinion concluding that the German participation exemption regime for dividends originating in third countries is contrary to the free movement of capital.

Read the article.


First bilateral APA signed with United States

Tax officials in India signed the first bilateral advance pricing agreement (APA) with the United States.

Read the article.


APAs on treatment of advertising, marketing, and promotion expenses

The Central Board of Direct Taxes announced the conclusion of two advance pricing agreements (APA) addressing the treatment of advertising, marketing and promotion expenses.

Read the article.


Revisions, updates to APA rules and MAP guidelines

The Malaysia Inland Revenue Board amended the rules applying to advance pricing arrangements (APA) and revised the mutual agreement procedure guidelines.

Read the article.


EC state-aid investigations, whether tax rulings provide 'unfair advantage'

The European Commission (EC) opened an in-depth investigation concerning two Dutch tax rulings and whether they may have allowed a company to pay less tax and provided an ‘unfair advantage’ over other companies, in breach of European Union state aid rules.

Read the article.


Bonus shares not under fixed exemption as work-related costs

In a case concerning whether the allocation of bonus shares falls under the fixed exemption of the work-related costs rules, the Amsterdam Court of Appeals held that the allocation of bonus shares to a select group of employees was ‘unusual’ and therefore not within the standard criterion under generally accepted standards for purposes of the work-related costs rules.

Read the article.

New Zealand

BEPS implementing legislation would affect related-party loans, transfer pricing rules

A bill concerning base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) has been introduced in New Zealand that would implement the government’s policies concerning BEPS matters.

Read the article.


Voluntary assets and income declaration scheme and responsible tax

Nigeria’s Voluntary Assets and Income Declaration Scheme (VAIDS), launched as of 1 July 2017, gives defaulting taxpayers the opportunity to make up their outstanding tax obligations from 2011 to 2016 in return for waiver of penalty and interest and criminal prosecution.

Read the article.


Summary of 2017 tax developments

Nigerian Tax Journal 2018 provides a round-up of 2017 tax developments, including tax cases, regulatory changes and administrative pronouncements.

Read the article.


Guidelines for mutual agreement procedure

The Ministry of Finance in Norway published mutual agreement procedure guidelines that apply under Norway’s network of income tax treaties.

Read the article.


Court decisions: finance leases, tax loss carryforwards; new withholding tax regime

KPMG in Oman summarizes the outcome of recent tax litigation involving:

— the classification of finance leasings for tax purposes
— the ability to carry forward of tax losses incurred in a period In which the taxpayer is tax-exempt

KPMG in Oman also summarizes changes to the country’s withholding tax regime.

Read the article.


EC opens investigation of tax incentive for Polish shipyards

The European Commission opened an investigation into a Polish tax incentive that gives shipyards operating in Poland the option of paying a 1 percent flat-rate tax on sales from the building and conversion of ships, instead of paying the generally applicable corporate or personal income tax rates.

Read the article.


Rules of origin for EU-originated goods, customs duties

The rules for certificates of origin for goods imported into Turkey from the European Union have been simplified with measures that took effect 28 February 2018.

Read the article.

United Kingdom

Penalties for inaccuracies in returns and documents

A policy change of HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) regarding the penalty for inaccuracies in returns and documents is important for employers who are subject to HMRC reviews of their PAYE/benefit records.

Read the article.


Redenomination of qualifying corporate bonds

The UK Court of Appeal found that provisions allowing bonds to be redenominated to euros if the UK changed its lawful currency do not prevent bonds from being qualifying corporate bonds.

Read the article.


Loan notes received by employees not restricted securities

The Upper Tribunal held that loan notes received by employees are not restricted securities for UK income tax purposes.

Read the article.


Proposed profit apportionment of taxpayers in oil and gas sector

The First-tier Tribunal ruled that a proposed profit apportionment for oil and gas companies was just and reasonable.

Read the article.


HMRC interpretation of termination payment rules

HM Revenue & Customs confirmed its interpretation of the commencement provisions for the new rules on non-contractual pay in lieu of notice. The new rules apply to payments made on or after 6 April 2018 where the employment ended on or after 6 April 2018.

Read the article.


Updated MAP statement of practice and associated guidance

The new Statement of Practice and guidance from HM Revenue & Customs on the mutual agreement procedure gives further assistance to UK taxpayers seeking relief from double taxation.

Read the article.


HMRC guidance on end-use relief

New guidance from HM Revenue & Customs on the application of end-use relief will affect businesses importing goods when the use or end destination is not known.

Read the article.

United States

Foreign tax credits for ‘compulsory levies’ paid by Mexican branch

The US Tax Court held that Mexican taxes paid by a US taxpayer’s Mexican licensee were ‘compulsory levies’ eligible for foreign tax credits.

Read the article.


No capital gains treatment of royalties, “all substantial rights” in patents not transferred

The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed a US Tax Court decision that a taxpayer was not entitled to capital gains treatment on patent-generated royalties because the taxpayer had not transferred ‘all substantial rights’ in the patent.

Read the article.


Statute of limitations for certain omissions of gross income

The US tax court held that the 6-year statute of limitations period, expanded in 2010 for reporting requirements for ‘specified foreign financial assets’, has effect only for tax years to which the reporting requirement is applicable.

Read the article.


IRS practice units: Adjustments to debt basis, stock basis ordering rules

The Internal Revenue Service’s (IRS) Large Business and International division publicly released two ‘practice units’ part of a series of IRS examiner ‘job aides’ and training materials intended to describe for IRS agents leading practices about tax concepts in general and specific types of transactions. The new practice units address:

— adjustments to debt basis – read the article

— stock basis ordering rules – read the article


Certiorari granted in South Dakota case seeking to overturn Quill

The US Supreme Court granted certiorari in a case in which South Dakota seeks to have the court uphold a statute imposing economic nexus standards on remote sellers. In its petition for certiorari, South Dakota asked the court to revisit and abrogate the sales and use tax physical presence nexus requirement upheld in Quill v. North Dakota.

Read the article.


LB&I directives on transfer pricing examinations

The Internal Revenue Service’s Large Business and International (LB&I) division publicly released a set of five directives as guidance for examinations of transfer pricing issues.

Read the article.


IRS concludes some foreign currency agreements are not insurance

The IRS publicly released a Chief Counsel Advice memorandum that determines an arrangement involving foreign currency fluctuations between an affiliated group and a related captive insurer does not constitute insurance for federal income tax purposes.

Read the article.


False Claims Act violations: Cautionary tales when customs declarations are falsified

An announcement from the US Justice Department warns US companies of their potential liability when they or their business partners or suppliers falsify customs declarations.

Read the article.


Loan guarantees by CFCs includible in taxpayer’s gross income

The US Tax Court found that a US shareholder of two controlled foreign corporations (CFC) that had in turn guaranteed loans made to a US person must include the CFCs' applicable earnings in its gross income and that the amount so included is taxable as ordinary income.

Read the article.


Adequate disclosures to reduce accuracy-related penalty

The Internal Revenue Service’s new Revenue Procedure 2018-11 identifies circumstances when a disclosure on a taxpayer’s income tax return with respect to an item or position is adequate for reducing the accuracy-related penalty under section 6662(d) of the Internal Revenue Code and avoiding the tax return preparer penalty under section 6694(a).

Read the article.


Effects of tax returns filed with Virgin Islands’ tax bureau

The US Tax Court released a ‘reviewed opinion’ in which the court – noting that a non-resident of the US Virgin Islands having both US and Virgin Island income must file a return with the Virgin Islands Bureau of Internal Revenue (VIBIR) and also with the IRS to satisfy the requirement to file a return under the Internal Revenue Code – concluded that the VIBIR’s sharing of information with the IRS amounts to filing a return.

Read the article.


Adjusting tax attributes under centralized partnership audit regime

The US Treasury Department and Internal Revenue Service proposed regulations addressing how partnerships and their partners adjust tax attributes to take into account partnership adjustments under the centralized partnership.

Read the article.


US company settles alleged false statements on customs declarations

The US Justice Department announced that a company headquartered in Tennessee agreed to pay 500,000 US dollars (USD) to resolve allegations that it violated the False Claims Act by making false statements on customs declarations in an effort to avoid paying antidumping duties on wooden bedroom furniture imported from China.

Read the article.

These articles represent the views of the authors only, and do not necessarily represent the views or professional advice of any KPMG International member firm.The information contained herein is of a general nature and based on authorities that are subject to change. Applicability of the information to specific situations should be determined through consultation with your tax adviser.


Related content