According to the European Commission, the VAT split payment mechanism infringes both EU VAT rules (Council Directive 2006/112 / EC) and the freedom to provide services (Article 56 TFEU). Romania has requested a derogation for the application of this mechanism, but this has been rejected by the Commission.
It is expected that the Romanian authorities will have to eliminate the VAT split payment mechanism.
Cartrans Spedition SRL (hereinafter referred to as "Cartrans" or "the Company"), a taxable person established in Romania, acted as road transport services broker. For certain transactions, the tax authorities refused to apply the VAT exemption because the company could not provide the customs export declarations (hereinafter referred to as "DVEs") to show that the goods were actually exported.
In Case no. C-495/17 Cartrans, the Court of Justice of the European Union ('the ECJ') ruled that the exemption applicable to transport services directly linked to the export of goods cannot be made conditional solely on the presentation of the DVE. As long as the supply of services contributes directly to the actual carrying out of the export operation, the ECJ has ruled that the application of the exemption can also be supported by a TIR carnet addressed by the customs authorities of the third country of destination of the goods as long as its authenticity or reliability cannot be challenged.
The ECJ, by means of this decision, clarified that the DVE is not the only document which may be used to justify VAT rexemption for services related to the export of goods. However, the ECJ's ruling in Case C-288/16 LC should also be taken into account. This states that the exemption may be applied only to those services provided directly to the consignor or consignee of those goods.
Thus, we recommend that carriers should carry out a rigorous analysis of these transactions to determine the extent to which the VAT exemption can be justified.
© 2020 KPMG România S.R.L., o societate cu răspundere limitată de drept român, membră a reţelei de firme independente KPMG afiliate la KPMG International Cooperative („KPMG International”), o entitate elveţiană. Toate drepturile rezervate.
KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”) este o entitate elveţiană. Firmele membre ale reţelei de firme independente KPMG sunt afiliate la KPMG International. KPMG International nu oferă servicii pentru clienţi. Nicio firma din reţeaua KPMG nu are autoritatea de a obliga KPMG International sau oricare altă firmă din reţeaua KPMG faţă de terţi, şi nici KPMG International nu are autoritatea de a obliga o altă firmă membră din reţeaua KPMG.