20RU-022 Negative interest rates – Financing arrangements
20RU-022 Negative interest rates
Australia is currently experiencing historically low interest rates and we may experience negative interest rates. This Reporting Update considers the potential impacts on financing arrangements and any associated risk management strategy.
On 3 November 2020, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) reduced the official cash rate, the 3-year Australian Government bond yield target rate and the Term Funding Facility rate from 0.25% to an historic low of 0.10%. In the short-term markets, the 3-month Bank Bill Swap Rate (BBSW or BBSY), continued its downward trend and traded at 0.02%. Although Australia has never experienced negative interest rates, it is now a real possibility and there have already been instances (intra-day) where the interest rate forward curve has dipped into negative territory.
Globally, several other countries have had negative interest rates for some time, however, it is the first time that Australian interest rates have fallen this low. New Zealand is also experiencing very low interest rates for the first time, and similarly the BKBM (the New Zealand benchmark) forward interest rate curve has slipped into negative territory in recent times.
Potential impacts on financing arrangements
Theoretically, when the benchmark rate becomes negative, lenders will be paying, rather than receiving, BBSW to their customers on loan arrangements. In practice, given the margins on borrowings, it is not expected that the overall interest rate will drop below zero.
However, to protect lenders’ exposure to negative interest rates, it is now not uncommon for lenders to insert a minimum or zero interest floor clause in loan agreements. For example, a floating rate loan priced at BBSW3m plus a 2% margin may now have a clause that there is an interest rate floor of 0% on the BBSW3m component. When BBSW becomes negative, the borrower would only pay the 2% margin to the lender with the BBSW component fixed at zero.
What is the issue?
In order to manage the floating interest rate exposures arising from loans, entities commonly enter into interest rate derivatives to mitigate their risks and designate these derivatives as cash flow hedges for accounting purposes. For cash flow hedge purposes, entities hedge the variability due to the BBSW component on the loan and not the margin.
However, unlike the more recent loan agreements which have included interest rate floors on the benchmark rates, interest rate swaps typically do not contain any floors. As a result, there will be no corresponding offsetting impact from the loan in a negative interest rate environment.
For example, an entity has a loan paying BBSW +3% with a floor of zero on the BBSW component. It enters into an interest rate swap where it agrees to pay 4% and receive BBSW. Under this strategy, when interest rates are positive, there is an economic relationship between the loan and the interest rate swap which results in the entity fixing its interest rate at 7% (3% margin plus 4% on the swap). However, in a negative interest rate environment, it will result in paying more than 7%. For example, if BBSW is negative 1%, the entity will pay 5% under the swap, and 3% on the loan, a total of 8%.
Accordingly, where a loan (hedged item) contains a floor for the benchmark interest rate and it is hedged with an interest rate swap (hedging instrument) that does not contain a similar floor on the benchmark rates, questions such as whether the interest rate swaps are still appropriate for the purposes of achieving the documented risk management strategy and the impact on financial reporting will arise.
What are the potential accounting implications?
A number of financial reporting implications could arise from a negative interest rate environment depending on the entity’s risk management strategy. For example, where the interest rate exposure is hedged, all or part of the change in fair value of the derivatives may be recognised in the Income Statement as hedge ineffectiveness. In certain scenarios, for example, where it is expected that the benchmark rates will remain below the floor for an extended period, the relationship could fail hedge accounting. In addition, key financial ratios such as interest cover ratios will be impacted.
Actions to take
- Identify whether there are interest rate floor clauses in loan agreements and understand the application of those interest rate floor clauses (e.g. whether floor is applied on BBSW or BBSW plus margin)
- Determine whether derivatives such as interest rate swaps used to hedge these loans have a similar interest rate floor
- Review the set-up of loans in accounting systems to ensure the change in cash flows of the loans incorporates the impact of the interest rate floor
- Assess whether any impacted hedge relationships continue to meet the criteria for hedge accounting, and
- Quantify any hedge ineffectiveness required to be recorded in the Income Statement.
KPMG Australia acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of the land on which we operate, live and gather as employees, and recognise their continuing connection to land, water and community. We pay respect to Elders past, present and emerging.
©2022 KPMG, an Australian partnership and a member firm of the KPMG global organisation of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Limited, a private English company limited by guarantee. All rights reserved. The KPMG name and logo are trademarks used under license by the independent member firms of the KPMG global organisation.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
For more detail about the structure of the KPMG global organisation please visit https://home.kpmg/governance.